10-Platform Seller Profit Comparison Matrix (2026)
Compare take-home profit, effective fee rates, and projected monthly earnings across all 10 major ecommerce marketplaces, live-shopping apps, resale platforms, and payment processors in one view.
Shared Product & Order Economics
All 10 Platforms Ranked by Take-Home Profit (United States)
Showing default regional rates. Click any platform to fine-tune ads, plans, or reverse pricing.
| Rank & Platform | Total Fees | Eff. Fee % | Net Profit / Order | Margin | Monthly Net | Calculator |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 Vinted 0% Seller Fee (UK #1) | -$0.00 | 0.0% | $33.00 | 66.0% | $3,300.00 | Open |
2 Shopify Lowest Per-Sale Fee | -$1.75 | 3.5% | $31.25 | 62.5% | $3,125.00 | Open |
3 Stripe Developer Standard | -$1.75 | 3.5% | $31.25 | 62.5% | $3,125.00 | Open |
4 Depop 0% Selling Fee (US/UK/AU) | -$2.10 | 4.2% | $30.90 | 61.8% | $3,090.00 | Open |
5 PayPal Global Checkout | -$2.24 | 4.5% | $30.76 | 61.5% | $3,076.00 | Open |
6 Etsy Handmade & Digital | -$5.20 | 10.4% | $27.80 | 55.6% | $2,780.00 | Open |
7 Whatnot Live Shopping Boom | -$5.35 | 10.7% | $27.65 | 55.3% | $2,765.00 | Open |
8 eBay UK 0% Private Seller | -$7.03 | 14.1% | $25.97 | 51.9% | $2,597.00 | Open |
9 TikTok Shop Fastest Growing | -$7.50 | 15.0% | $25.50 | 51.0% | $2,550.00 | Open |
10 Poshmark Flat 20% / $2.95 | -$9.00 | 18.0% | $24.00 | 48.0% | $2,400.00 | Open |
Head-to-Head Fee Comparisons (A vs B)
Vinted vs Depop
Vinted lets sellers keep 100% of their listed price (0% total seller fees), beating Depop's payment processing cut (~2.9% + £0.30 UK or 3.3% + $0.45 US)—though buyers pay the Vinted Fee at checkout.
Vinted vs eBay
In the UK, both Vinted and eBay Private charge 0% seller fees! In the US, Canada, and Australia, Vinted's 0% seller fee saves ~13%+ per sale over eBay's standard Final Value Fee.
Whatnot vs eBay
Whatnot (~10.9% all-in on standard categories, or ~6.9% on Coins) undercuts US/CA/AU eBay (~13.25%+) and saves massively on $1,500+ grails via its 0% high-value cap.
Whatnot vs TikTok Shop
TikTok Shop US (6% organic) is cheaper than Whatnot (~10.9%) when you drive your own live traffic—but once you pay 10%–15% TikTok creator affiliate commissions, Whatnot keeps more per unit.
Vinted vs Poshmark
Vinted saves sellers a full 20% on items $15+ compared to Poshmark—keeping $10 more on every $50 sale—while Poshmark offers stronger US luxury/branded buyer volume.
Whatnot vs Depop
Depop keeps ~7.5% more profit per piece in US/UK/AU thanks to 0% selling commission, while Whatnot trades higher fees (~10.9%) for rapid bulk liquidation during live shows.
Etsy vs Shopify
Etsy wins for $0 fixed startup cost and built-in search discovery; Shopify wins on per-order profit margin once you generate consistent repeat or self-driven traffic.
TikTok Shop vs Etsy
Without creator affiliate payouts, TikTok Shop US (6%) takes less per order than Etsy (~10%+). Adding a 10%–15% creator commission makes TikTok Shop costlier per unit but drives higher viral volume.
TikTok Shop vs Shopify
TikTok Shop acts as an acquisition channel with $0 monthly cost; Shopify maximizes long-term margin and customer ownership at ~2.9% per sale.
Depop vs Poshmark
In the US, UK, and Australia, Depop leaves sellers with dramatically more cash per sale (~3.3% + $0.45 processing) than Poshmark's 20% commission—unless you use Depop's 12% Boosted Listings.
eBay vs Poshmark
eBay typically takes 6%–7% less in fees than Poshmark on items over $20, though eBay charges fees on shipping and sales tax too.
eBay vs Depop
In the US and Australia, Depop's 0% selling fee beats eBay's ~13.25% FVF by ~10% of the sale price. In the UK, eBay private sellers (0% total) edge out Depop's 2.9% payment fee.
Stripe vs PayPal
Stripe is cheaper than standard PayPal Checkout in the US, UK, and Australia—saving $0.78 per $100 in the US and over £1.50 per £100 in the UK.
Etsy vs eBay
Organic Etsy sales (~10%–11% total) generally cost less than US eBay (~13.25% + tax fee)—unless Etsy Offsite Ads (12%–15%) apply.
Shopify vs eBay
Shopify saves roughly 10% per order compared to US eBay fees—meaning just ~$400/month in direct sales covers a Shopify Basic subscription.
TikTok Shop vs eBay
TikTok Shop's base referral fee (6% US) is less than half of eBay's standard 13.25% US FVF, though adding a 10% creator affiliate rate reverses the cost advantage.
Etsy vs Depop
For vintage fashion sellers in the US, UK, and Australia, Depop's 0% selling fee (~3.3% payment fee) saves ~7%–8% per sale over Etsy.
Shopify Payments vs Stripe
Card processing rates are nearly identical in the US (2.9% + $0.30), while Stripe beats Shopify Basic slightly in the UK (1.5% vs 2.0%)—but Shopify adds a 2% penalty if you bypass Shopify Payments inside a Shopify store.
eBay vs PayPal Invoice
Invoicing direct buyers through PayPal Goods & Services saves ~9%–10% compared to eBay US fees while still offering buyer/seller dispute protection.
TikTok Shop vs Depop
Depop keeps per-unit fees lowest for single-SKU vintage fashion (~3.3% US), while TikTok Shop excels when you have deep inventory to scale via video views.
Shopify vs Poshmark
Shopify saves roughly 17% per sale compared to Poshmark—selling just $250/month of boutique apparel directly covers Shopify's Basic plan.
Etsy vs Poshmark
Etsy takes roughly half the commission of Poshmark on organic sales (~10% vs 20%), making it much more profitable for curated vintage and handmade boutiques.