Etsy vs Shopify Fees Calculator (2026)
Etsy wins for $0 fixed startup cost and built-in search discovery; Shopify wins on per-order profit margin once you generate consistent repeat or self-driven traffic.
Shared Product & Order Economics
Shopify saves $3.45 per order
At 100 orders/month, that equals $4,140.00/year in extra take-home profit.
Etsy
$0.20 listing + 6.5% transaction + 3% + $0.25 processing
Shopify
Higher Profit2.9% + $0.30 (Basic) down to 2.5% + $0.30 (Advanced)
Best for Etsy
New handmade/vintage sellers needing built-in buyer demand with zero monthly overhead.
Best for Shopify
Growing brands with $600+/mo in self-driven or repeat sales wanting to cut per-sale fees by ~65%.
Outgrowing Etsy's 10%+ per-sale fees?
Keep Etsy for discovery, and send repeat customers to your own Shopify store where you only pay ~2.9% card processing.
Etsy vs Shopify FAQ
Which has lower seller fees in 2026: Etsy or Shopify?+
Etsy wins for $0 fixed startup cost and built-in search discovery; Shopify wins on per-order profit margin once you generate consistent repeat or self-driven traffic.
When should I choose Etsy over Shopify?+
Etsy is best suited for: New handmade/vintage sellers needing built-in buyer demand with zero monthly overhead.
When should I choose Shopify over Etsy?+
Shopify is best suited for: Growing brands with $600+/mo in self-driven or repeat sales wanting to cut per-sale fees by ~65%.